Monthly Archives: October 2009

Thank you…

I just wanted to give a quick word of thanks for the guest reviewers who helped out over the last two weeks. Colorado was beautiful, warmer than usual (though still darn cold to me!), and an enjoyable vacation. I’ll be back to my irregular schedule this week.

Anyone who was thinking of sending a guest review but didn’t make the deadline can still send guest reviews in if they’re still interested. I’m sure I’ll have other vacations (or times when I’m sick or the like) in the future and can post them then.

Take care!

Guest Reviews – Sea of Insanity

Heyla all! Assuming the auto-updater actually works properly, this will show up while I’m freezing my extremities in Colorado while hunting Elk armed with a digital camera (because no one is going to trust me with a hunting rifle! Besides, hunting licenses cost money!); actually, I’m accompanying my father after years of his offering to take me along. Assuming everything goes well, I should be back before Halloween. And if it doesn’t… well, that’ll explain the lack of updates. Guest reviews will be up on October 14, 20, and 25.

Seeing that I’m entirely too lazy to write up reviews ahead of time, I put out a call for guest reviews. This is the third of the reviews, by Roland Hansson, and of a comic that I first encountered before I was writing reviews, and which vanished into the mists of hiatus years ago. Fortunately, unlike so many others of its kin, this superb comic has returned. And now, the guest review:

——————

Sea of Insanity
by L.K. Malnassy

Reviewed by Roland Hansson

Genre: Urban Fantasy
Rating: PG-13
Update Schedule: Erratic, currently averages 1 per week
Format: Varies, from comic strip to whole-page format
Art: Pencils, overwhelmingly B&W, occasional guest art

The first clue Finn, shiftless college student, gets that something is amiss with his new shared apartment, is when he steps into the living room without looking, and plunges into a lake.
He finds himself living together with an ancient Greek fertility spirit named Isle, her ever-hungry giant python and, soon after that, with her unfortunate psychologist, Gil Surgen, who has acquired a tendency to turn into a fish at regular intervals.

Why, incidentally, does Finn chose to stay in this weird apartment in the first place? His own words: “In case you haven’t noticed, my life is boring as hell. Why WOULDN’T I want to live with a neurotic nymph and her giant carnivorous snake?”

* * *

Now, after this short description, you would expect this comic, “Sea of Insanity”, to be a comedy romp – and there are indeed often laughs to be had. Isle’s visitors include a ditzy oread, a mischievous muse and a horny centaur. However, at the core of this story are elements of tragedy…

Isle’s ex-boyfriend is the greek god Apollo, God of light, truth, intellect – and, apparantly, of really shitty relationships.

When he hooked up with Isle, Apollo gave her what she most wanted – Intelligence. Before, she was dim. Now, she excels at sarcastic wit. Before, she couldn’t read. Now, she makes her living writing lyrical poetry. Before, having a god for a boyfriend was pretty cool. Now, she’s aware of what happened to all of Apollo’s former girlfriends – and she wants out, before she’s turned into a tree or worse.

Apollo doesn’t take hints. He doesn’t take no for an answer. He shows up to woo Isle and harass her cohabitants. He is determined to win over Isle – NOT because he loves her, mind you, but because he needs to win a bet. Oh boy, does he need to win that bet.

Apollo is powerful. He has a temper. He gave Isle her intelligence. And what the gods give… the gods may take away.

Let me repeat that. Apollo has the ability to LOBOTOMIZE Isle with a snap of his fingers.
Isle, of course, is fully aware of this. She even has had notice from the friendly neighborhood oracle – prophecy is against her.
To conclude, things don’t look good.

***SPOILERS BELOW***

Eventually, of course, things came to a head. Apollo showed up when Isle was alone, and after heated argument, Apollo left for good, taking his gifts with him. ALL his gifts.

Our view of Isle after this event has been limited. She went through phases – locking herself into her room, immersing herself in physical relationships – only lately has she started communicating with her worried roommates.
(As an aside, portraying a character whose intelligence has changed so drastically – and still conveying the same personality – must be a real challenge to a writer. LKM does pretty well.)

So far, this is good drama. But the kicker, as I see it, is that Apollo isn’t actually too bad a guy. We’ve occasionally followed his POV, and he obviously has his own problems. We’ve seen him drinking himself to oblivion, grieving a friend. His brother Hermes, and Zeus, his father, have been missing for many years. And losing the bet will put him at the mercy of Aphrodite, who wants him dead.
After he leaves Isle that fateful night, Apollo tries to justify his actions, his treatment of women, to himself, but fails. His anguished words at the end: “Oh Father, why can’t I stop?!”

And THAT, to me, is what makes this tragic.

*** END SPOILERS ***

What lies in store for our protagonists? The comic still has a long way to go; there are a lot of prophesies to be fulfilled and many plot threads to be resolved (I have only touched a few in this review). At a guess, we’re at most a third into the actual story – I get the feeling LKM is setting the scene for the REAL story to begin.
I have no idea what will come next – “Sea of Insanity” is ever surprising – but one thing’s sure: it’s going to be entertaining, to find out…

Guest Reviews – A Girl and Her Fed

Heyla all! Assuming the auto-updater actually works properly, this will show up while I’m freezing my extremities in Colorado while hunting Elk armed with a digital camera (because no one is going to trust me with a hunting rifle! Besides, hunting licenses cost money!); actually, I’m accompanying my father after years of his offering to take me along. Assuming everything goes well, I should be back before Halloween. And if it doesn’t… well, that’ll explain the lack of updates. Guest reviews will be up on October 14, 20, and 25.

Seeing that I’m entirely too lazy to write up reviews ahead of time, I put out a call for guest reviews. This is the second of the reviews, by HiFranc (who has recommended this comic to me in the past).

—————–

Review of A Girl and Her Fed:

When Otter, the artist, started her style was very different to what it is now.  She is in the process of updating the archives to make the art consistent throughout, and to correct plot holes and pacing.  At the time of writing (August 2009) the update is not yet complete so the old strips form the middle if you go to the new archives.

I’ll warn you now that there is a lot of swearing in this comic and there are a few bedroom scenes.

To get an idea of the art and a quick introduction to two of the characters here is the first page:

The first page as it originally was:

The new version of the first page:

The comic is about a young woman (the “Girl” of the title), who is in touch with the ghost of Benjamin Franklin.  At the start she thinks he’s just a hallucination because she is the only person who can see him.  The Government is keeping an eye on her because for some reason she’s unjustly listed on a no fly list.  She is also an unpaid intern for a newspaper.

The agent (wait for it….the ”Fed” of the title) who has been assigned to her has his own invisible friend.  He is part of a secret programme where a chip has been inserted into his head and the display is projected in mid air such that only people in the programme can see it.  The interface looks like President Bush.

Someone connected to a local politician dies and our heroine[1] decides to investigate.  The agent decides to help her so the two of them start following the clues.  The comic follows them on their mission to discover the truth.  It also charts their relationship.

Otter has informed us that the comic will end when the adventure is over.  The plan is for the comic to finish sometime in 2011.

How else can I describe the comic?  The plot is based on at least one conspiracy theory.  There is a mixture of light hearted strips and deadly serious ones.  The humour comes mostly from the interactions between the characters and some that you would expect in a sitcom.  In its own way it pokes fun at the paranoia that has engulfed most countries since the events of 2001.

How would I summarise its style?  The first thing that I can think of is: MASH meets Enemy of the State (but our heroine and hero are far from helpless).

In short, if you want a fun conspiracy thriller with a lot of humour, ghosts and strange characters then A Girl and Her Fed is the comic for you.  If that doesn’t grab you then you’re probably best giving it a miss.


[1] Sorry for the lack of a name but the author has specifically hidden that information from her readers.

Guest Reviews – Weesh

Heyla all! Assuming the auto-updater actually works properly, this will show up while I’m freezing my extremities in Colorado while hunting Elk armed with a digital camera (because no one is going to trust me with a hunting rifle! Besides, hunting licenses cost money!); actually, I’m accompanying my father after years of his offering to take me along. Assuming everything goes well, I should be back before Halloween. And if it doesn’t… well, that’ll explain the lack of updates. Guest reviews will be up on October 14, 20, and 25.

Seeing that I’m entirely too lazy to write up reviews ahead of time, I put out a call for guest reviews. This is the first of the reviews, by one of my competitors contemporaries, the WebcomiCritic. So if you’re surprised by the change in writing style and different style of graphics… well, I didn’t write it. No doubt it’ll be a vacation for all of you as well. Meanwhile, enjoy!

——————–

Review Number 1: Weesh

Hello I’m the WebcomiCritic, I do it because, well… Somebody has to!

Good god, where have I been? when was the last time i reviewed something, a month? I’m losing my touch and I don’t even have it yet! That’s the LAST time I accept an offer to go to New Orleans for a month!

Now, how are my fans (Or Lack thereof.)?

DEAR LORD! Okay Okay okay! I’ll make it up to you, All four of you! here is it, right here, one bonifide review, ready for the world to draw its opinions from…

All kids would want a genie. All adults would want a genie. ANYbody would want a genie. Okay, maybe not everybody (FOOLISH GIRL!), but They’re seriously just cool. I think Aladdin may have influenced that, but let’s face it, who wouldn’t want a being that could grant your every wish? Pretty righteous, huh? Heck, if people asked what kind of superpower I’d want, I’d say wish-granting (Subset of Reality bending ^_^).

Why about wishes? Well look at the title of this comic, it’s called freaking Weesh. Sound like anything to you? This comic is AWESOME. Okay, maybe not “awesome” but “adequately satisfying!”

Unlike my usual Newbie Rants, this comic is made by a veteran webcomic artist known as Dan Hess. Mr. Hess is famous for his works such as Angel Moxie, Realms of Ishikaze, and Rebus.

Well, in July of 2008, Mr. Hess enters the webcomic scene once again with kid’s story about wishes…


When I first saw this comic I was drawn in by the art. Not by how clear, crisp and cute it was (Okay, maybe it was) but I couldn’t help thinking “Where have I seen this artwork before?” Further research led me back to Angel Moxie, a webcomic I couldn’t quite get into in my younger days. In retrospect, Angel Moxie rules as a parody of the Magical Girl genre and plays it straight at the same time. Also, you can really tell how much the art has improved and yet you can tell it was the same guy who did it, even though it seems almost radically different.

With that said, I guess I’m talking about the art style first. it fits the tone of the comic very well. It’s smooth, innocent, and has a very flexible feel. The large heads and skinny bodies can be difficult to pull off but this guy has it down to a science. The characters are appropriately designed, including the title creature, Weesh. It has a very unique design. You dpn’t see too many green bunny/kangaroo-like thing with stumpy legs and a stringy tail granting wishes. He went out of his way to make a unique design and I’m proud of him for that. Mr. Hess also has backgrounds down perfectly. but then, he’s a veteran and a professional, should we expect anything less?

The style makes me think anime super deformed (cute and tiny breaks from the ordinary style for comedy and silliness.) but apparently Mr. Hess knows haw to make laziness and turn it into hard work.

What’s more, he’s flexible. He has backgrounds and scenery down and he’s able to do a good mecha and monster. I still can’t do anything good beyond drawing people!

Now, the story is as good as any story will get. He’s put the comic in the format of a 4 panel gag-a-day, similar to Angel Moxie, only Angel Moxie had a plot. this is basically something a person would find in the newspaper. In fact, it’d be perfect as a newspaper comic, good money made that way. No! Wait! It’s too good for that! It wouldn’t be appreciated in the Washington Post, you deserve better. All shall know your greatness in another way… By why should they? I found you, you belong to Moi! No newspaper, nobody, NOTHING shall ever have you, my precious Weesh…

Uh, with that unhealthy moment of obsession aside… The stories are focuses around some wish the youngest two kids make and it’s results and consequences. Unlike most stories about wishes *coughfairlyoddparentscough* Mr. Hess doesn’t try to bore us with morals and aesops and run them into our craniums. the kids don’t care to learn lessons and aren’t willing to learn. Therefore, we continue with cute, innocent, lighthearted fun. Of course the lesson of how one phrases their wishes remains.

Another fascinating plotpoint is that Weesh is still in-training. When he isn’t messing up a wish because of wording, it’s because he’s not good enough. Hilarity ensues. It’s also a convenient plot device that Weesh isn’t good enough because it means that the wishes don’t last longer than approximately ten minutes. Hooray for Convenient and Clever Cover-ups! It’s like the gift that keeps on giving. Mr Hess created the perfect formula to create perfectly reasonable comic that can perpetually keep itself running for years to come and remain entertaining, provided some jokes aren’t recycled too quickly or he falls victim to Cerebus Syndrome. I doubt it though, the odds are horribly unlikely.

the characters are decently made as well. they’re 2 dimensional enough to be interesting and keep the plot going. Can’t be too 3 dimensional, heaven forbid a real story kicks in. The characters are the 3 Merle kids and genie; Weesh.

The youngest child is the impossibly innocent Olivia. she’s the quintessential 5 year old girl. She’s every stereotype you’d ever suspect to find in a little girl, innocent, cheerful, optimistic, has absolutely no idea of the consequences behind her actions, and she likes dollies and flowers…

My god, I can’t believe I wrote that. just thinking about her gives me goosebumps! What’s scarier is that Mr. Hess doesn’t subvert this character archetype; he embraces it. Most people usually reveal to us that their version of this character is secretly evil or a short and violent temper. But, no. This limits her wishes to the cute, innocent, and fun things in life that you’d expect any irresponsible and naive little kid to ask for. She also follows Mr. Hess’s tradition of incorporating one small, young, innocent, childish female character. Hooray for Recycling! Or maybe just a theme or motif, whatever it may be, he seems to make it work,

Next we have the middle child, Tate, who gives the feel of being at the most, 3 years older than Olivia. He represents the quintessential young boy who’s interested in aliens, rockets, monsters, jungles, and adventure. And to pump this up to the max, he’s a sci-fi geek. He makes the most wishes from what I’ve observed and hangs out with Weesh the most. Probably because his big sister doesn’t care and his little sister isn’t smart enough to realize Weesh’s true potential. But not only as a tool does he treat Weesh, but as a best friend. Like many boys his age, he’s easily bored and his attention span is abysmal. But let’s face it, if you have a wish granting kangaroo/rat thing you would be as bored as sin with everything else.

And finally, Zoey, the stereotypical quintessential young teen rebel girl filled with sarcasm, sardonicness, and apathy. Who could ask for more? Who cares if she’s also a walking stereotype, I’m a sucker for these characters. she may not be the life of the party but she certainly puts her own spin on things. Her general apathy towards Weesh is a bit discomforting. The ability to have wishes granted before she gets too old and she doesn’t give rat’s hind-corners? What has age done to this poor girl? She thinks these things out way too well! Well, except for when it really matters. Though, like most characters of her build, she has a heart somewhere in there.

And then there’s Weesh himself. He’s the reason why morals don’t get shoved down our throats. He doesn’t learn, thus destined to repeat the same mistakes for whichever family he meets. Weesh is the second most sarcastic character, Zoey being numero one. This guy is lazy and laid-back. He’s no walking stereotype unlike the rest of the family, unless you want to draw some Garfield parallel and even that’s stretching it. This guy is original in so many ways which I will get to soon.

Like now. This guy is pretty creative, I must give Mr. Hess points for originality. I mean, Weesh first and foremost. He’s no traditional genie, in neither appearance nor origin. His limitations aren’t rules (so far) but instead by how much licorice he can eat. Yes, a wish granter powered by licorice! The characters act like a big happy family rather than making Weesh a tool. They can confide each other in the silliest or most serious of things. And the wishes are about what any kid would wish for. I’ve seen Fairly Odd parents, most of those wishes are far too ridiculous to be relateable. The Rule of funny rules that show while the rule of… Everything Good rules Weesh.

Speaking fo funny, Yes, Mr. Hess has good jokes. Unfortunately they tend to fall flat. I don’t mean they’re bad nor poorly executed. They’re just kinda “meh”. You’ll good a smile, sometimes a chuckle, maybe even a laugh if he was feeling good that day. But not something I’ll be rolling on the floor in laughter with. The jokes aren’t by any means bad, but defiantly not top notch. Merely above adequate.

And that’s Weesh, I have nothing bad to say in a humorous manner about this one. Sorry folks, I’ll try to be more critical next time, but I’ll need a fairly repulsive comic to do it.

Until next time. I wanted to finish off with a Weesh quote, but this one really stood out.

“How can anyone ignore puppies?”-Olivia

-Read or Die you Uneducated Buffoons
The WebcomiCritic

Website Update

As I mentioned a couple months back, I’ll be vanishing for a couple of weeks in the middle of October. In fact, I’ll be leaving for the wilds of the Colorado mountains armed with a digital camera to hunt the wily elk (because hunting licenses cost money! That, and who’d trust me with a rifle?). Fortunately, I was able to get three guest reviews by the deadline, and have managed to load them into the system. Assuming the auto-updater works properly and that the upgrades that are occurring to my DNS name server while I’m on vacation don’t interfere with the updates, then updates will occur on the 15th, 20th, and 25th of October. If my vacation is cut short (poor weather or the like) and I return home to New Hampshire before the 26th, then I’ll see about other updates as well.

Meantime, enjoy the guest reviews. And a special thanks to The WebcomiCritic, HiFranc, and Roland Hansson for submitting guest reviews early. I just wish I’d not procrastinated on posting them to my site!

Rob H.

Red String

For all my love of the webcomic genre, I must admit there is one inherent flaw that webcomics suffer compared to their print brethren: the tendency of readers to view a webcomic update as a single entity, rather than part of a whole. While this doesn’t matter for gag-a-day comics such as xkcd or Penny Arcade, for storytelling comics such as Footloose or Megatokyo, this can be at times problematic. Nor is this only a matter of drawing in new readers, who gain their first impressions of a comic by whichever page is present when they stumble across a comic; current readers can get quite vocal at perceived flaws in a comic’s update when in fact the seeds of the incident were planted several comics back.

One example of this can be found with the romantic comic Red String, and fan reactions to the latest update. Often those webcomic forums that have achieved critical mass to gain an active community tend to have bursts of activity, often centered around favored characters who end up in emotional situations. This is especially true for ‘shippers, or fans who are passionate about the pairing of characters they consider favorites; the smallest of signs can often result in ‘shippers ending in a frenzy of forum posts wailing on how long it’s taking or how stupid such-and-such a character is and how they need to just open their eyes or the like. (I must admit, I was once a part of the ‘shipper community in one forum, though character actions later made me realize that the relationship wasn’t going to happen.)

Recent events in Red String have indeed sent ‘shippers into a frenzy; the very title of Chapter 35, “Friends No More” and the poses of two of the characters left many hoping that secondary characters Reika and Eiji would finally hook up. (And yes, these ‘shippers are as passionate over their select characters as the most die-hard of soap opera viewers are of their select shows.) The latest update, with Reika smacking Eiji upside the face after he prevents her from running off, resulted in a bit of frothing in the forums, with some fans complaining how it’s “okay” for girls to hit guys, others wailing about how Reika’s an idiot, and of course some declarations of fan-hate of Reika. About the only thing that is missing from this brouhaha is declarations of “I’ll never read this comic again!” and that was visible a week prior (and resulted in cartoonist Gina Biggs taking a break from the forums because she didn’t want to deal with the bs and fans refusing to wait until the chapter end before rendering judgment).

The problem lies in part with reading the comic as an independent entity, rather than part of a whole. When starting at the start of the scene, the situation is explained better. Reika is not only in a situation where she’s feeling uncomfortable and embarrassed, she also is just now having her feelings for Eiji pointed out to her by Eiji’s older brother, Ken’ichi. Right after that revelation, Reika and Ken’ichi walked in on Ken’ichi’s girlfriend Aiko hitting on Eiji (with Eiji trying to get away from Aiko), and the stage is set for a slap that may be unwarranted, but is definitely understandable.

While I rather enjoy the new update format for RS, I do have to wonder if Biggs might be better off taking a page from fellow cartoonist Sarah Ellerton. Ellerton’s comic, The Phoenix Requiem, updates twice a week, but with each update consisting of two or three comics. Ellerton also works to pace those pages so they work together in mini-arcs that blend in with the previous story comics… but are not as confusing on their own. This problem with being blinded from the story with the latest update can also be cured with occasional short archive crawls; by rereading segments of the comic (primarily with the latest storylines), fans can better get an understanding of the context of the update as part of a whole, instead of on its own.