Tag Archives: Homosexuality in comics

Taiki

Around three years ago, I reviewed a coming-of-age comic called Taiki about a teenage girl in high school. While I initially considered the comic to be yet another high school comic, Taiki ended up being more about Taiki’s realization that she was gay, and her relationships and friendships while in school. Still, I must admit one of the reasons I read the comic was it was on my update schedule; there weren’t really any special moments or elements that stood out and encouraged me to review the strip after the initial review.

This saddens me as the notable event that has finally drawn a Secant from me is cartoonist Laura Knatt’s decision to wrap up the comic with Taiki’s graduation from high school. While Knatt originally intended on the storyline continuing past high school, her decision to end things here make sense. The comic first began when Taiki started school (though I don’t recall if she was in her Junior or Senior year; she was sixteen, so it seems likely the comic went through a couple years of school). Thematically, ending things now creates a proper sense of closure for the strip.

If there’s one problem that Taiki suffered from, it would be the diffuse nature of the strip. The comic accurately portrayed the lack of purpose that many teenagers in high school suffer from… but when telling a story, it’s helpful to have a clear objective in mind. The lack of a significant plotline resulted in the comic drifting from story to story without leaving a true impact. This isn’t to say the comic wasn’t enjoyable; it is (and worth reading even as it has ended). But while the comic touches upon several elements including a young lesbian’s realization of who and what she is, it failed to impart much emotion into these revelations.

Serenity Rose

Imagine for a moment you lived in a world where superheroes existed. Mind you, I’m not talking about street vigilantes that put on a mask and beat up criminals with their fists or whatever weapons are available. I’m talking the real thing – demigods that walk the Earth, with the power to snuff out mere humans with a gesture or a glare… men and women who can affect reality, whether with eye-beams, super-strength, or mental talents to bend the minds of others to their will. If you think of it, it’s actually a fairly horrific concept. The sense of powerlessness would be overwhelming. What’s more, it would be very easy to think of these beings as something… Other. Not human. And thus, to be scared of.

This theme of the Other is an aspect of Aaron Alexovich’s Serenity Rose, the story of a petite shy young woman who is one of 57 Witches in the world, each of whom has the ability to alter reality, create monsters out of ectoplasm, and more. Not only does Serenity stand out due to her appearance (as she has blue hair and greyish skin), but she’s been persecuted for her talents by people who are scared of the Other, including by the U.S. Government. When you get down to it, however, there is a legitimate reason for people to fear Sera as some of her nightmares came to life… and hunted down and murdered people who weren’t a threat to her. Fortunately, Sera herself was horrified to learn of this and has worked to try and keep her nightmares leashed.

Interestingly, there is another aspect of the Other with Serenity – her sexuality. To be honest, I don’t recall this aspect of her being used to play up the theme of Other with our protagonist; Sera has a difficult enough time finding friends, so her sexuality (and her attraction to other women) hasn’t really seemed a significant part of her person. This could just be inattentiveness on my part, I must admit, as I came into the comic midway into the last chapter when she was being stalked by a homicidal witch (along with an adversarial government that believed her a threat). But the current story (with the subheading “Break Your Stupid Heart”) has shifted gears from Sera learning more of who and what she is from her new mentor, the witch and singer Vicious Whisper, and swerved to a coffee date with a young woman who played an import part in her teenage years, Maddy Price.

Naturally the date is getting all awkward, seeing that Sera believed that Maddy hated her (as Maddy was harassed by her fellow students after being outed as a lesbian and Sera believes she failed to protect Maddy)… and Maddy herself has some issues with witches outside of Sera. And it’s this that brings back the theme of the protagonist as Other. Maddy describes the other witches as “disaffected daydreamers” though she quickly reassures Sera that she didn’t mean to lump her in with the others, stating that she’s not been coddled and seems almost… human. At which point Maddy gets annoyed at herself as I get the feeling things aren’t going the way she played it out in her own head. Though I must admit, I’m going to be rather amused to see what happens when Maddy takes Sera out for some (alcoholic) drinks as she keeps inserting her foot in her mouth even when sober.

The interesting thing is, given Maddy’s own past and the harassment she suffered in school for being lesbian, I could see her having some level of understanding with Sera. While there are some significant obstacles between the two of them building a romantic relationship (their own shared past, Sera being a witch and Sera’s feelings about other witches, and Sera’s own shyness and difficulties relating to other people), Maddy is an important aspect of Sera’s life, despite their not seeing one another for seven years. Yet I’m unsure as to how large a role she’ll play; the most important elements of Sera’s life (her best friend, her mentor, even the antagonist from the previous chapter) have held a flash of color for them to stand out. This seems to be lacking for Maddy; whether or not she’ll grow into this role remains to be seen.

General Protection Fault

Perhaps one of the most common calls of armchair critics is that a character is a “Mary Sue” (which to me is a very overused term, especially when you consider the original “Mary Sue” was a parody character poking fun at the character type as a whole). But while the term has lost any real value due to its overuse and abuse, there is a core aspect to “Suedom” inherent in a number of characters… because those characters can be seen as an aspect of the author (or at the very least a character mouthpiece). It’s easy for readers to believe a character’s prejudices and beliefs actually reflect those of the author, especially when a character is developed further than a shadow with minimal definition or personality. Thus unfortunately authors sometimes attempt to sanitize their characters to prevent any controversies.

The sad thing is, it can take very little to create such perceptions. One such example can be found in the recent Global Protection Fault comics, with Fooker and Patty talking about Tim (another of the tertiary characters)… and his reaction when she implies to Fooker that Tim might be gay and seems to be attracted to Fooker. Okay, I’ll admit that if I was trying to put computer memory into a server and was told that a coworker was gay and into me, I might break the memory as well. But mostly it’s Fooker’s facial expression and how he worked things that hints to me that while Fooker might say he doesn’t care what people do privately, he personally doesn’t approve of homosexuality. And while I suspect cartoonist Jeffrey T. Darlington may not intend to imply this, I think it would be an interesting path to take with Fooker.

Let’s be honest here; while there is growing acceptance of homosexuality and the LGBT movement, prejudice is an ingrained trait for people. We can overcome it, but deep down there is still that tiny germ waiting to sprout at the most unexpected moment. Thus I feel it would be interesting (and valuable) to see this potentiality with Fooker expanded upon. Let him have a personal aversion to homosexuality… and show his efforts to keep this from influencing how he reacts to Tim or to other homosexual men if Tim is in fact straight – I’m afraid I don’t recall one way or another, though if Tim is gay, then Darlington has done fairly well at subtly introducing this element, laying the groundwork until Patty launched a salvo to disconcert Fooker.

Of course, this could just be Patty trying to disconcert Fooker, who’d been needling her about her own semi-relationship with Dexter. And let’s be honest here; Fooker was out of place to press her about things with Dexter. But if it were just Patty “getting even” with Fooker, it was in rather poor taste. What’s more, I’d be interested in seeing this element expanded upon. Things such as hidden prejudices tend to be ignored by cartoonists due to the ease of internet drama and reader misconceptions. While Fooker has never been a “perfect” character, his relationship with Sharon is stable now, his distrust of Trudy is understandable, and his other “flaws” tend to be lackluster or laughable. And to be honest, it’s Nick that is the author’s mouthpiece, so any flaws Fooker show can be brushed off as storytelling elements.

Webcomic News – Taiki

I just wanted to give a quick shout-out to the high school webcomic Taiki (which focuses on a young lady in high school who realizes she’s lesbian and comes to terms with who she is). My hat’s off to cartoonist Laura Knatt, who’s been drawing and writing Taiki for six years now. Congratulations, Laura, I look forward to your next milestone, and seeing where Taiki’s story takes her and you.

Questionable Content

Sometimes I feel guilty about how much attention I give to Jeph Jacques’ slice-of-life science fiction webcomic Questionable Content, but I do feel today’s update is worth a quick nod seeing its relevance to my previous review in July concerning the germination of Dora and Tai’s romantic relationship… which involved Tai confronting Dora and outright telling her about her interest (sober, this time). To be honest? I didn’t think Jacques had it in him. We went for a thousand updates before Faye finally told Marten “sorry, but no.” Dora herself has grown increasingly insecure after her own breakup with Marten (which is understandable, seeing she instigated its demise, though his passive aggressiveness didn’t help).

So to see Tai take the cow by the horns and force an answer out of Dora? No. I didn’t see that coming, especially not on a Monday. I can’t help but wait for the other shoe to drop – maybe Tai gets fired for abandoning her job to run off for a booty call, or Dora’s therapist ends up saying it’s a bad idea and convincing Dora to call things off. Despite my pessimism, however, I must admit that Tai’s thoughts on this are quite mature. If it doesn’t work out, it doesn’t work out. These things happen. But refusing to try because you might get hurt is no better. Loneliness sucks, especially when it’s self-inflicted… and Dora has been punishing herself ever since she broke things off with Marten due to an over-developed sense of guilt despite the fact Faye is quite happy with someone else now.

Who knows, maybe it’ll work out. I suspect I’m not the only reader who kept expecting Dora and Marten to ultimately get back together again, and pushing Dora into another relationship helps kill those last diehard romantics. Besides, Jacques laid the groundwork for Dora and Tai back when Marten was still with Dora. Those initial seeds have taken a while to sprout. And ultimately, Questionable Content is Marten’s story. He’s been able to reclaim a tiny bit of the old friendship he once held with Dora. Having her happy in the arms of another may allow Jacques to slowly fade Dora into the background, her story mostly complete, while Marten continues on in his own quest for self-awareness and happiness.

Questionable Content

Looking back, I just realized it’s been over four years since I last wrote a proper review for Jeph Jacques’ slice-of-life science fiction webcomic Questionable Content. Since then I’ve written 18 additional articles on a variety of topics (making QC one of my most commented-on comics, which is undoubtedly due to Jacques’ skill in making fascinating and enjoyable characters), but the last real review was back in Feb. 28, 2008 review (concerning Faye’s hookup with Dora’s brother Sven). And to be honest, my initial plans for today’s comic was just that – another quick one-paragraph commentary on the potential hookup between Tai and Dora. However, I realized this would be leaving a lot unsaid on the topic, including considerable growth that the characters have undergone.

The seeds for a Tai/Dora relationship were actually planted way back when Dora was still dating Marten, which makes me wonder if Jacques may have planned the breakup of Marten and Dora back when Tai first entered the scene. While I don’t have time for a proper archive crawl to verify my suspicion, if I remember right, Tai was strongly attracted to Dora even back when she was still dating Marten, and was going through a bit of angst after Marten had broken up with Dora (because it’s one of those unspoken rules that you don’t date the ex of a friend, at least if you want to keep that friendship). Finally Marten himself gave Tai the go-ahead in what was likely the final sign that there was no hope for a ressurected relationship between Dora and Marten. (The fact it also showed Marten was healing and showing considerable maturity is beyond the point.)

The big question, naturally, was how Dora felt about Tai. While it’s somewhat obvious that Dora is bisexual (given she was flirting with both Faye and Marten early in the series), I don’t really recall Dora seeing a lot of Tai even when she was dating Marten. In many ways, Tai was outside Dora’s social circle and I don’t think she had the courage to approach Dora on her own. Thus Dora’s own enthusiastic greeting of Tai shocked both Tai and myself, especially given she’d gone out with a date with her counterpart at The Secret Bakery not that long ago. Interestingly, while she told Tai the same thing she told Jim, that she’s a mess and not really ready to date… Tai didn’t let that deter her.

When you get down to it, Tai’s dead on in her reasoning. Everyone has issues they’re dealing with. Dora’s problem is that she holds herself up to a higher standard. She’s working on her trust issues. And I half suspect the reason she’s not dating anyone else is she feels guilt over what happened with Marten, even though he’s moving on (and indeed did date someone else who I suspect he’d still be happily with if she’d been able to stay). But what’ll be interesting is to see how Tai changes.

Up until now, Tai’s been a bit of a free spirit. She’s bounced from relationship to relationship, and while she’s sometimes expressed a desire for stability, I have to wonder how she’ll handle being with just one person. Can she let opportunity pass her by, or will she succumb to temptation, much as Sven did? Personally, I hope Jacques relies on more than just his imagination in crafting any potential romance between Tai and Dora. While Questionable Content is in many ways a comedy, I would love to see a realistic depiction of a lesbian relationship shown in the days ahead, rather than the cheap fantasies that so often litter the internet.

Supernormal Step

Every so often I stumble across a comic that I have difficulty easily summing up. These unfortunate (and often creative) works often languish in my reading queue until I either forget I’ve never reviewed them or lose the initial creative urge to critique the comic in the first place. This is the sad lot that the alternative reality/superhero webcomic Supernormal Step fell into a couple years ago, and since that time I’ve enjoyed it while procrastinating on writing an actual review. Fortunately for SS, another comic just recently crossed my radar and displaced it on the procrastination table so I figured I’d see if the Muse would be interested in writing this comic up. She was.

The comic focuses on the dimensionally-displaced heroine Fiona Dae, a young lady from Earth who has found herself displaced to another Earth where people have magic (but no guns), humans are just one of a multitude of intelligent species, and the U.S. government is a benign dictatorship under a man named Henderson who provides security and some semblance of order, in return for being the undisputed ruler of the nation. Of course, how benign he is depends on just who you ask, and there’s naturally a Resistance of sorts that is trying to get Fiona to work for them, even as Henderson tries to get her to work for him (even while claiming she could leave anytime she wants to).

As with most stories in the Transference genre, Fiona is intent on returning to her old world (which is of course easier said than done). This is despite the fact that in this new Earth, she has learned magic and has become a bit of a hero (having fought a giant wolf at one point, as well as a band of villains who’d been hired by the Hendersons to identify who the dimension-traveler was, and who don’t know when enough is enough. Part of this lies with her upbringing; her father was apparently a survivalist and a vigilante who home-schooled her, resulting in Fiona being… paranoid about letting people get close (as well as dying her hair blue so she’s not reminded of her dad when she looks in the mirror). Despite this, she’s become friends (of sorts) with the two people she first met in this alternative Earth, a heroic sorcerer named Van who has this talent at attracting women, and a cursed hero named Jim who tends to turn into a stuffed rabbit whenever he acts too arrogant or is caught in a lie.

More recently, there’s also Akela, a four-armed blue-skinned lady who started helping her investigate the Hendersons and who has apparently started to fall for Fiona. In this, cartoonist Michael Lunsford has actually taken a rather realistic approach; Fiona hasn’t shown attraction for anyone at this point (being focused on returning back to her Earth, though this seems to be more due to her being constantly weirded out by this alternative Earth than because of family or friends back there), and Akela even admits to herself that it’s probably a lost cause. I must admit I’m rather taken by this approach to a relationship. I could see it going one of three paths, with Fiona not being interested (in Akela or in girls in general), a relationship forming, or even Fiona not quite realizing until she finally has a chance to go back to her own world… but realizes she’d have to leave Akela. No doubt there are other paths as well.

Interestingly, the Hendersons are also being developed further, specifically with Hall Henderson (who has also shown a bit of interest in Fiona, though I’m not sure if he’s romantically interested in her as his partner Eva implies, or if he’s fascinated with her situation) learning he’s not the first (or only) Hall Henderson… and realizing that his boss, Mr. Henderson, is up to something. What this is has only been hinted at (though it may have something to do with dimensional transit), but in all likelihood as the story’s climax approaches we’ll see Hall (and his older incarnation) drawn back into Fiona’s story, even as she’s dragged (screaming and kicking) into an ultimate confrontation against Mr. Henderson.

Needless to say, the story’s grown rather complex and involved at this point with four years of archives (even with some occasional breaks and intermittent updates), but during this time Lunsford has created an impressive mix of characters. The obvious star of the story is Fiona, but that doesn’t diminish the stories of the other characters (though Jim seems more of a two-dimensional jerk who only avoids Mary Sue territory due to the curse he suffers under). And I must admit I’m curious as to what Akele’s story is, especially as she suddenly moves to share the stage with Fiona. I’m not exactly sure where Lunsford is going with Supernormal Step, but he has created something quite unique, and more than a little fun.